She’s seeking sole custody? Is she trying to alienate me from my kids!

Jack is furious that Jill is seeking sole custody of their two children. He regards himself as a father who has always been involved with his children, and believes that he has much to offer his kids, both in terms of decision-making and in terms of the time they spend together.  Jack views Jill’s actions post- separation as an overt attempt to cut him out of the children’s lives, and “alienate” them from him. But is this the proper use of the term, “parental alienation?”

A parent who engages in alienating behaviour deliberately and actively campaigns to estrange his or her child from the other parent. Specifically, an alienating parent will talk negatively about the other parent or treat that parent disparagingly in the child’s presence; he or she may tell false stories and lie about the other parent directly to the child. Such parents will not allow their children to speak openly about the other parent in positive terms, or relate positive experiences they have had with the other parent. Moreover, alienating parents may subject their children to interrogation immediately following their return home from access visits, or create divided loyalties by refusing to allow the child to wear clothing purchased by the other parent or bring gifts home from the other parent.

 

Such behaviour on the part of the alienating parent typically occurs over extended periods of time. In response, a child who is alienated will consistently express negative feelings about a parent, or outright reject a parent, for reasons which are unjustified given the child’s past relationship with that parent and given the rejected parent’s conduct itself.

Courts must assess allegations of parental alienation on an individual basis, in order to determine whether a child’s fear or rejection of a parent is reasonable and justified given the circumstances of that particular case.  Was this child previously abused by her parent? Does the parent routinely miss or cancel access visits? What type of relationship did the child have with her parent prior to separation? If a child has valid reasons for exhibiting fear of his parent, or if there is a history which explains why the child refuses to attend access visits or engage with his parent, then it is inaccurate to claim that the child is alienated. If, on the other hand, a child who used to enjoy a loving and meaningful relationship with her parent is now truly fearful of that parent, or outright hostile toward that parent, then parental alienation may be at issue.

The court’s role in custody and access cases is to determine what is in the child’s best interests; it is not the court’s objective to reward or punish parents for their behaviour. Therefore, how courts respond to cases where parental alienation exists is not uniform. In certain cases, reunification or reintegration counselling may be recommended; a complete change to the existing custody and access regime may be ordered. In other instances, courts may find that to order any change to the status quo would cause further harm to the child.

So if you believe that your ex-spouse may be engaging in an alienating behaviour, don’t jump to conclusions.  Seek the assistance of a mental health professional who will be able to guide you through this process and make proper recommendations as to an intervention plan which may, or may not, involve hiring a lawyer.