Who needs a lawyer? Let’s settle this between us!

Jack is ready to officially move out of the home as he wants to get on with his life.  Since he expects to have significant parenting time with the children, he rented a home which he now needs to furnish.  For that reason, he had a discussion with Jill this morning and gave her a list of things he wants to take with him including furniture, electronics, tools and other household contents.  He also proposed to Jill a way of dividing equally between them their debts, car payments, home expenses and other monthly liabilities.  Jack was told by his best friend Mark that everything needs to be divided 50-50, so that’s how he suggested that he and Jill divide their debts and expenses.  Jill seemed satisfied with the proposal and Jack started drafting a brief separation agreement confirming the parties’ decisions.  After all, Mark and his ex-wife did it this way, they had no problems and they saved a lot of money. In addition, Jack has a copy of Mark’s separation agreement and so it should be relatively easy to just copy the relevant provisions.

For many good reasons, resolving the issues between you and your ex as quickly and cheaply as possible should be your ultimate goal during the separation process.   However, there are a few caveats you should be aware of when you decide to put a family settlement in writing without the assistance of a qualified family lawyer, or at least some guidance from such a professional. Too often, what appeared to have been a simple issue can turn out to be a very complex and expensive one.   When it comes to resolving family law matters, the agreement or the piece of paper signed by both parties may not be a binding contract recognized by the legal system.   In fact, it can be challenged on various grounds and the judge hearing your case may later decide that your “agreement” is null and void.

The first thing you must understand is that in family law, for a contract to be valid it must at least be dated and signed by the two parties before a witness.  Secondly, it is possible for the person who challenges the validity of the agreement to argue that the contract should not stand because he or she:

• Did not understand the nature of the contract, its content or consequences
• Was forced to sign the contract by some form of duress, pressure or undue influence
• Signed the contract without financial disclosure, or
• Feels that the contract is simply unconscionable (i.e. completely unacceptable in  the eyes of the law)

Finally, to make sure that the contract you signed will be enforced by a court if ever challenged by your ex-spouse in the future, you should always obtain independent legal advice (i.e. ask a family lawyer to review your agreement before you sign it).  Make sure that your ex-spouse ALSO gets legal advice but from a different lawyer (the same lawyer cannot give you both legal advice).  If you don’t, you may very well have to deal with the same issue all over again in the future, and at a much higher cost. When advising you on your separation agreement, your family lawyer will make sure that you fully understand the content of your agreement, that you are not signing the contract out of duress or some other form of pressure, and that the financial disclosure obtained from your former spouse allowed you to make informed decisions.

Who said you can keep the car and the investments too?

The Christmas holidays are over and Jill is very happy that things went much better than she anticipated with Jack and the children over the Holidays.  Since their separation in August, Jill has become more financially astute and received as a Christmas gift from her father a book entitled “The Wealthy Barber Returns” (click here to have a peak at that book) which she read while the children were visiting with Jack.  She truly enjoyed this book which explains in a simple and humorous way important financial concepts she needs to understand in order to move on with her life post-separation.  The new year has just begun and Jill feels it is now time for her and Jack to begin discussing how they will divide their family property (assets and debts).   Jack must have read her mind because he sent her an email this morning listing the items he wanted to keep including the new car, the plasma tv, the bedroom suite, and more of the “good stuff”.   That really upset Jill as she felt Jack was only thinking of himself, once again.  Out of exhaustion, she is thinking that it might be better to just let him have his way to finish this off quickly.

When anger is high and feelings are hurt, disputes over the division of household contents often turn into endless emotional battles during the separation process which fuel the litigation and can significantly increase costs to both parties’ detriment.  Remember that what you “feel” is yours may not necessarily be so in the eyes of the law.  Similarly, assuming that you are entitled to «half of everything » just because you were married is not necessarily true either.  To reach a quick settlement and to reduce the stress, some people are tempted to rush through the process of dividing their family property. Others mistakenly believe that dividing everything in half (splitting every asset and every debt in half) is the simplest and fairest way of dividing family property.  Thinking that the settlement was fair they then chose to sign a “kitchen table” agreement (i.e. one drafted by themselves without legal advice) to put the issue behind them.

In reality, dividing your assets and debts, while it does not have to be a complicated, requires a much deeper analysis in most circumstances and should never be accomplished without a deep understanding of the long-term consequences of any given property settlement.  Doing so could result in a settlement that is completely unfair to you and / or which may have very serious financial consequences in the future which you were not aware of.  A separation agreement should never, (and I repeat) never be signed unless you have spent at least one hour with a family lawyer who can explain to you what you are fully entitled to by the law, what you may be leaving on the table and what the long-term financial implications of your decisions will be. Experience has shown that settlements which seemed simple and fair at first glance do not necessarily stand the test of time and you would not want to be eating cat food just because of hasty decisions you made to settle your separation quickly. 

Can I stay financially afloat on my own?

Jill has not been sleeping well these past few weeks.   She is extremely worried about her financial future and is wondering if she can stay financially afloat on her own. She has been working part-time since the birth of the children and she may now need to go back to work full-time. Jill was somewhat aware of the household finances but Jack was the financial planner and decision maker. Jill can barely function at work or at home and the thought of having to become financially knowledgeable overnight is overwhelming. She is angry at Jack for putting her and the children in this financial mess.

When facing divorce, people don’t always get what they think they deserve financially.  Some make hasty decisions because they are anxious to get the divorce over with.  Some hope to reconcile and for that reason don’t ask any questions to avoid alienating their spouse.  Others are angry and let their emotions in the way of a fair and reasonable settlement, thus increasing legal fees unnecessarily.  We have all heard horror stories about how divorce can be devastating financially to one or both parties.  However, divorce does not have to lead to bankruptcy or a negative bank balance. Consulting professionals such as financial divorce specialists, mortgage specialists, accountants  and appraisers (to name only a few) will help you assess the real value of your assets, understand any tax implications involved in any settlement and plan for your financial future.  Educating yourself will be your guide to financial freedom.  Here are a few ideas for you to reflect on:

1. Keep your expectations about money realistic.  Expect that money will be tight – for a little while – and that you may not be able to maintain your present lifestyle even if you are fairly wealthy.  It will be frustrating at times to think of what you had and what you have “lost”.   Think of your separation as a temporary financial set-back.  Like the fluctuations of the stock market, with a long-term financial plan, some patience and a bit of luck, lost money can always be re-earned.

2. Equitable does not mean equal.  A long drawn out separation battle definitely drains emotions and finances.  Be willing to negotiate as you have a limited supply of time, money and energy.   It is not about getting all you can get.  Understanding that equitable does not mean equal may help you strive to achieve a win-win situation and may save you time, money and energy in the long run.  

3. Think long term.  Keeping a handle on the financial implication of any decisions you make can avoid many long term pitfalls.  Deciding whether to keep the convertible BMW you always dreamed of instead of a mutual fund may mean that you will be eating cat food in a few years.  If you don’t know the answer or where to start, consult a financial expert who can help you see what today’s financial decisions will mean in ten years.  

4. Get involved in planning your financial future. The rule of thumb is to keep it simple and get involved.  Make a budget and a list of your debts and assets.  You can have a short-term (before final settlement) plan and a long-term (after settlement) plan.  Your separation will take some time before it gets resolved.   Therefore, take it one step at a time.

Why is the date of separation important?

Jill has made it quite clear that she did not want to continue to live with Jack in their family home and as a result, Jack has been looking at his options.  Jack knows that Jill has spoken to the bank and was pre-approved to purchase a new home, a move he clearly disagrees with. Jack is also getting extremely concerned about various withdrawals made by Jill against their joint line of credit without his knowledge or consent ($1,500 one week ago paid by cheque to “Albert & Albert Law”, $2,000 which was transferred  to her personal bank account and another $500 the destination of which he does not know).  Jack knows that these withdrawals will not bankrupt the family, but he sure disagrees with having to pay one half of Jill’s lawyer’s fees!

Are you having similar concerns?  If so, then it is essential for you to understand the concept of the “date of separation” and its importance in your divorce or separation.  In all Canadian provinces and territories, spouses have the right to ask that their family property be divided equally (or fairly, depending on the province or territory) between them.  Most provinces and territories confine this right to married people ONLY. As a result, if you are living in a common law relationship in one of those provinces, the rules concerning the division of your property will be different. What is important to remember is that in most Canadian jurisdictions (including in the province of Ontario), when you are married it is not the property itself that gets divided (in species), but rather its value.  What value do you use? In most provinces (including in the province of Ontario), the property subject to division is valued as of the date of the parties’ separation.  This means that in principle, whatever happens after the date of separation is irrelevant to determine each party’s entitlement to a share of the parties’ family property. 

Let us make it more simple. In the case of Jack and Jill, if Jack was to win one million dollars one day after the date of separation, he would not have to share it with Jill.  Similarly, if one week after the separation Jill was to take a $50,000 personal loan to purchase a brand new Mercedes, Jack would not be entitled to share the value of the Mercedes, but nor would he be liable for the $50,000 debt.  It is very important to keep in mind, however, that while Jack does not have to assume one half of Jill’s $50,000 debt, if Jill was to use the parties’ joint line of credit to purchase the car, Jack may become liable towards the bank for the entire amount.  When negotiating their settlement, Jill will have to account to Jack and reimburse him for any liability (i.e. debts and bank withdrawls) contracted by her after the date of the parties’ separation. 

How do we determine the date of separation?  The date of a couple’s separation is not the day the parties signed a separation agreement, nor the day that their divorce is granted.  The date of separation, in very simple terms, is the day that one of the spouses communicates to the other his or her intention to separate in a way that makes it clear that there is no possibility of reconciliation. For most couples, this date will be quite clear (in most cases one of the spouses moves out of the home that very day, or shortly thereafter), but for some other couples it will not be that clear and it will be a question of evidence if the spouses later cannot agree on a specific date.  Also remember that it is possible (and in fact very common) to be considered separated even if you continue to live under the same roof.