An offer to settle? Is my lawyer losing trust in my case?

The trial in Jill and Jack’s family matter is approaching.  They have not yet been able to settle their disputes over financial matters and the judge overseeing their court case has advised them that he was “setting this matter down to trial”. Family judges often do that to force the parties to be reasonable and be pro-active about settling their affairs. As a result, Jack’s lawyer has recommended that an offer to settle be made to Jill, emphasizing the fact that the offer is a significant compromise on Jack’s part. In other words, Jack’s lawyer is proposing to settle financial matters for an amount significantly less than what Jacks believes he is entitled to.  Jack wonders why he would do that and is beginning to think that his lawyer may not be advising him properly.

 

In fact, this is really good advice that Jack is getting. The role of offers to settle in a family court proceeding must not be understated, as they can have a significant impact on the dollars you might be able to recoup at the end of the day.  If accepted by your ex-spouse, an offer to settle will end your court case definitely.  This means, among other things:

• No more legal fees to pay (thousands and thousands of dollars of savings);
• You will not have to go to trial (no need to spend an entire week – or more – under stress, telling a perfect stranger about your most private affairs with your ex-spouse);
• No more stress over the legal proceedings (sleep at last); and
• The right for you and your children to live in peace, and finish grieving the end of your relationship. 

If your offer is not accepted by your ex-spouse, then making a « low ball » offer to settle will have the effect of protecting yourself against the high costs of divorce litigation. At the end of a full-blown trial, the judge will have the obligation to consider costs spent by each party in the court proceeding, and to award costs in favour of one party against the other.  This means that the judge will have the right to order one party (usually the party who “lost”) to pay to the other party (the “successful” party) an amount to compensate him or her for the legal fees paid throughout the proceeding.  The judge will look at the offer to settle that was presented before trial. If some of the terms of the offer were more beneficial to the other party then what was ultimately offered by the judge, the court is directed by law to make a cost order against the party who failed to accept this most beneficial offer for the time wasted going to trial. As a result, a “low ball” offer to settle can become very beneficial in the end. 

 

Everything in family court is about being reasonable.  While you may think that you have a 100% chance of success in the position that you are advancing in court, history has shown that, in every single case, at least one of the parties end up disappointed.  Making every possible effort to settle your family issues out of court could mean accepting a bit less than what you think you are entitled to. Most importantly, it could mean finding peace of mind. Often, settlement is a question of perception:  is your glass half-empty or half-full?

 

I need closure!

Jill wants to have the home transferred to her name.  She knows that it is over with Jack and she’s chomping at the bit to build a new life.  She feels that Jack is purposely dragging out the separation process in an attempt to wear her down and get a sweeter financial settlement.  Her biggest fear is to settle too quickly and end up living from pay check to pay check.  

Here are 3 common mistakes people make when negotiating a settlement:

1. Insist on keeping the home you worked hard for or that you like so much
Often, the matrimonial home can be more of a liability than an asset especially when you are living on a single income.  It is important to make a list of all the monthly expenses before making this big decision.  It is also recommended to add 25% to your current monthly budget because with time, you will need extra money to get the roof repaired, a new fridge and stove, a lawn mower, new furnace etc.   In the end, it may make more financial sense to sell the home and move into a smaller, more affordable property such as a condo, an apartment, or a smaller bungalow where the maintenance is taken care of or less costly.  Emotionally, it may also make sense to start fresh in a home more suited to your family’s current needs.

 

2. Get bogged down in the “I want” war
Too many separated spouses fight over possessions they want such as furniture, antiques, and knickknacks while losing the big picture in the process.  As a result, lots of time and money are wasted in petty battles.  Fighting over minor possessions just makes negotiations on the important issues, like the home, parenting issues and support (child and spousal), more difficult and lengthy.  It is important for you to become a savvy negotiator.  Make a list of the things that you absolutely want.  Also include in the list some of the items you are willing to let go.  Then “compromise” on the non-essentials and make it look like a win-win situation!

 

3. Be overly anxious to get closure or be afraid to be ridiculed by your ex
Too many people rush into settlement because they are seeking closure.  Others are afraid to be ridiculed by their ex and do not stand up their ground.  Sometimes the desire for closure or the refusal to speak up means the difference between a comfortable life and a marginal one.  Get involved, understand how the law works, ask questions and make sound decisions.  Remember that a piece of paper will not give you closure. Only time and working on yourself can do that. 

The children are finally 18, can I stop paying child support?

Jack’s brother, Sam, has twin daughters (Melany and Stephany) who will soon be 18 years old and who continue to live primarily with their mother since the separation. The adult girls have just graduated from high school.     Melany has been working in retail since she is 16 years old and in light of the career opportunities offered by her company she has decided for the time being to work full time in that industry and not pursue her post-secondary studies.    As for Stephany, she aspires to become a doctor and has been accepted to university.  Following the completion of her bachelor degree in sciences, she hopes to enter medical school to pursue her dream.    For the next three years, both girls intend to continue living with their mother   Sam wonders whether he still has an obligation to pay child support after the girls turn 18.

Child support does not necessarily end when a child turns 18.  Normally, child support will continue to be paid for an adult child if he/she enrolls into  a post-secondary study program or if the child is unable to support himself/herself as a result of a disability or illness.  When a child pursues a college or university education the child support obligation will usually end when the child receives his/her first post-secondary degree, although there are exceptions.

To the extent that the obligation to continue to pay child support exists, the monthly amount of support must be determined. This is where things get a bit more complicated.  Normally, if a child lives at home with one parent while pursuing his/her studies, the basic child support amount that was payable prior to the child turning 18 will likely continue to be payable after that date (this amount is set by the Federal Child Support Guidelines, based on the payor’s income). This makes sense since the “custodial” parent will have to continue to maintain a home for the child and to assume his/her day-to-day expenses (i.e., transportation, food, clothing).    However, if the child movesaway from home to attend school (normally 8 months out of 12), then the way child support is calculated would be different as we would have to take into consideration the child’s needs outside of the parent’s home, the reduced costs to the recipient parent when the child is living away from home and the child’s own ability to contribute to his or her living and school expenses.

In addition to paying the basic child support amount, the paying parent (such as Sam) would also have an obligation to contribute his/her share of the child’s extraordinary expenses.  These would include a portion of the child’s tuition fees, books and other school expenses, to the extent that the child is unable to cover all of those expenses with student loans, grants or their own income.

 

Although it may appear that child support obligations will never end, just remember that you are a parent for life.  In the end, giving your child a chance at living a successful and financially independent life (hopefully sooner rather than later…) is what you are here for in the first place, isn’t it?

Should I go back to school as an adult student?

Jill is always struggling to make ends meet and she does not really like her job.  More than anything else, she hates to be financially dependent on Jack.  Since the separation, she is longing for a new exciting career with a higher income and better advancement opportunities.  Her greatest challenge is juggling home life, work and school.   Jill’s parents have agreed to help her out with the children during the school year.  However, they have a well-deserved retirement and Jill does not feel comfortable with imposing her family responsibilities on them.    Jill wonders if she should go back to school part-time or full-time, where she will take the money, the energy and the time to tackle this new life project. 

Here are four tips that can make an adult student life a bit easier:

1. Get Financial Help - Unless you have won the lottery or received an inheritance, money is the number one issue for adult student returning to school.  Ask your school for the various scholarships, grants and loans available in Ontario.   Often the applications must be sent several months prior to the beginning of the school year.  Make your budget, understand the debt repayment options available, as well as, the interest rates.  No sense accumulating a $50,000 debt that you will only pay off in 25 years!  Plan this out while you are at the negotiation table with you ex.  For example, you could try to negotiate a lump sum spousal support payment (one larger payment now rather than lower monthly instalments over a longer period of time).  You could also  ask for higher support payments but for a shorter period of time than the law would allow, which would give you the extra cash flow you need while attending school. 

 

2.  Plan study time in your busy schedule - Unless studying becomes your full-time job, you will have to juggle studies, children, and (maybe) a new relationship.  Managing your study time will be pivotal to your success.   Decide what hours/days you need. Making a date with yourself will help you stay focused and disciplined when something comes up during that scheduled time. Try to negotiate with your ex a parenting plan (access schedule) with the children that will give you the time you need to study.  You ex could be more than happy to help out with the children if, in the end it, your income is larger and you become less financially dependent on him or her.

 

3.  Reduce Test Anxiety – It is sad but true, with age and a surcharge of family responsibilities, our memory is not what it used to be when we were young and carefree students.  No matter how hard you study, tests are usually stressful.  Try to organize a special parenting arrangement with your ex during the weeks when you have exams.  School schedules are usually fixed a year in advance.  This gives you ample time to sort out, in  advance, a parenting arrangement for those weeks.  Being organized is the first way to reduce test stress, manage your anxiety and avoid last minute study cramming. When all fails, remember to breathe!

 

4. Create your support system -   Getting help from friends and family will be crucial during this very stressful and hectic time of your life.  Many schools offer group help and day-care facilities.  Friends and family may be more than happy to take the children for a meal and to special activities to help you out.  Don’t be shy and ask for help.  Get ideas from other adult students in your group. You might be surprised to see how many other single parents return to school and how resourceful they are when it comes to organization, household management and child care arrangements!

I want my divorce! What is the difference between separation and divorce?

Jack has had it.  If there was ever any possibility that they would reconcile, any such hopes have come to an end when he heard that Jill had retained the services of a lawyer. Jack has told Jill that he wanted a divorce, to which Jill has replied that he would get it “when he faced up with his responsibilities as a father and a husband!”.  Jack wonders if he needs Jill's consent to get a divorce.

 

When two spouses part ways, it is very common to hear them say that they “want a divorce”.  However, in a separation process the divorce itself is really just a legal formality that will put an official end to the marriage. Getting to the point where you can get a divorce is what takes so long and can be very difficult because in most cases you will want to settle all issues by way of a separation agreement.  Getting such an agreement through mediation, collaborative justice, lawyer-to-lawyer negotiation or a court process is your first step. When an agreement is signed, you then know what your rights and obligations towards your ex and your children will be in the future.  When all issues have been settled, getting the divorce is truly just a "paper process" which, while it still requires court intervention (the divorce can only be granted by court order), will not require the spouses to attend court and will not involve months of legal debates.  If you have been separated for one year and all issues have been settled in a separation agreement, you are entitled to obtain a divorce order with or without your ex’ consent.

 

This said, there is really no difference between being separated (once a final agreement has been signed by both parties) and being divorced, except for some of the following differences:

1. If you are divorced, you can get remarried (something you cannot do if you are not divorced).

 

2. If you are divorced, you may no longer qualify as a beneficiary under your ex-spouse’s health plan or pension plan (although certain health plans allows it in certain circumstances).  Some pension plans also require that you obtain a divorce order to prevent your ex to obtain, upon your death, your pension plan benefits.

 

It is common to see couples that never get a divorce and only have a separation agreement.  There is no difference in the eyes of the Canada Revenue Agency between a separated or divorced individual.  Often times, people are emotionally exhausted and simply do not want to engage any further legal costs getting a divorce until someone decides to get remarried.  For many people, however, getting a divorce is necessary to cut the emotional ties to their ex and many people get their divorce immediately after having signed their separation agreement. So ultimately, getting a divorce is, more often than not, simply a question of personal choice.

If I have to see you in court honey, you’ll have to pay my legal fees!

Jack and Jill have been trying to settle their separation issues by themselves for a couple of months now. Jill is getting frustrated with Jack because he does not seem to take their separation seriously.   She does not see any other options than to retain a lawyer and go to court.  She is convinced that once they go to court the judge will tell Jack what he needs to hear.  But when Jill finally met with her lawyer, she was a bit surprised by (and disappointed with) her lawyer’s comments and reluctance to engage into a court action.  She wonders if she hired the right lawyer…  In fact, Jill’s lawyer has explained to her that the court process is not only very time and emotionally consuming, it will also be very costly.  However, Jill is convinced that she will win hands down on all issues and that, in the end,  Jack will be responsible to pay for all her legal fees.

 

Many separated couples believe that going to court is the only way they can get someone to pay attention to what they are saying. They believe that they are right, the other spouse is wrong and that the court room will be the venue where the winner will take it all.   But legal fees to get there are a very important aspect to consider when making the decision to resort to the judicial system.  While a court may order the “losing” spouse to pay part of the other spouse’s legal costs to prepare and attend court, it is highly unlikely that the judge will order that ALL costs incurred be paid back to the “winning” party.   In addition, considering that most cases eventually settle out of court (less than 3% of all family court cases end in a trial, where costs orders are made), opportunities to get the big fat cost order are very rare.

 

In addition, it is not because a party wins in court the he/she will necessarily get his/her legal costs paid by the loosing party. In deciding whether a party should be responsible to pay for the other’s court costs, the judge will look at different factors such as: Were the parties reasonable?  Did the spouses make reasonable efforts to settle the case?  Did one of the parties fail to accept a reasonable offer? Did one spouse act in bad faith? Did one spouse pursue unrealistic claims? and the list goes on and on…

 

So no one should ever go to court thinking that they will win it all, or thinking that the other party will have to pay their legal fees.  When making the decision to go to court, you need to start from the premise that any and all legal fees paid to your lawyer will be on you, and that you will be lucky if at the end of the day a judge orders your ex to pay some of them.  This is why it is so important to make sure that you have tried every possible way to settle out of court before you chose this very lengthy and costly avenue.

All I need from my mom and dad after divorce

It is almost the end of the school year and the children have been coming home with their backpacks full of assignments that they completed in class with their teachers.  As Jack is sifting through the pile of papers on the kitchen counter, he found a wrinkled piece of paper written by his teenage daughter entitled: “All I need from my mom and dad”.   This is an assignment that was completed in English earlier in the year.  It broke Jack’s heart… Here’s what it said:

 

« All I need from my mom and dad »

•   I need both of you to stay involved in my life on a daily basis.  Please write emails, text me, make phone calls, and ask me LOTS of questions about school, my friends, my interests, my fears, my dreams and ambitions.  When you do not stay involved, I feel like I am not important and that you do not care about me anymore.
•   When you say you will visit me, make sure you show up because I feel so sad and lonely and often I feel the rejection over and over again.  I just want to spend time with you!
•   I want and I need to love both of you.  Please support the time that I spend with each of you and also with my step-parents.  If you act jealous or upset, I feel like I need to take sides and love one parent more than the other. 
•   Stop making me the messenger!   Communicate directly with my other parent. I often feel like the bearer of bad news and my stomach is in knots until I deliver the message. 
At my age, I don’t need this constant stress.

•   Always remember this:  I want both of you to be a part of my life on a daily basis. I count on my mom and my dad to raise me, to teach me what’s important, and to help me when I have problems.  I want to confide in you but before I do that I need to be constantly reassured that I can TRUST you and that you ARE there for me at all times!

As a parent, it is normal to feel uncertain about how to support your children during – and especially after – your divorce because often you simply do not know what to say to them.   Being a step-parent is even harder because you seem to be living in this grey zone – should I hug his/her children?  Tell them I love them?  Although they are not the parents, often step-parents are more involved in the children’s daily lives then the access parent.   The divorce is a transitional time that cannot be without some measure of hardship, but you can powerfully reduce your children’s pain by making their well-being your top priority.   If your children do not live with you primarily, do not fall into the trap of buying your children’s love with presents.  Give them the gift of time…

 

In the end, no matter their age and no matter the circumstances, all children want the same thing from their parents and step-parents such as reassurance, a listening ear, stability, routine and structure.  But most of all, children want to be part of a family that loves them and shows them every day by being present in their lives.  They want parents and step-parents to participate in their activities, to give them hugs and high fives and to take the time to cook and enjoy a nice family diner.  Simply said, your children need your presence more than your presents!